The Interview Rose by Elizabeth Smither
- NZ Booklovers
- 7 hours ago
- 3 min read

This is the twentieth collection of poetry from the celebrated New Zealand poet Elizabeth Smither. She also has six novels and six short story collections to her name.
These poems have a lovely selection of scenarios and locations. We travel the globe as far as the Gare du Nord in Paris and the British Museum in London.
We meet cows swimming, fish, garden frogs, a robot vacuum cleaner and have to brush the cat a hundred times. While one poem is about buying peonies, another one, entitled simply ‘Daisies’, does not take us in the direction we might have been expecting:
The lawn is gulping down the rain.
Drops, showers, downpours, and the daisies
respond in kind: one, a cluster, hundreds.
I think they do not fear the mower,
but like Marie Antoinette who said,
‘Excuse me, I didn’t mean to step on your foot,’
before she faced the guillotine
wearing a pure white dress
in the Place de la Révolution.
Another location which I really enjoyed was the sense that some New Zealand cities give when they have steeply rising hills on which the houses clutter the upper reaches. This poem is called ‘Houses on the Hill’:
I envy the houses on the hill
and their bold seizure of sky
and sun and stars and moon.
Most have shady trees for company
a canopy, a hedge of fur.
These hill houses have bare necks
and long windows whose light
and timing is out of reach. We
below switch on the prescribed lamps
but they are flooded, dawn to dark
by bands of light like premonitions
great swathes of war and peace.
The novels of Jane Austin feature heavily in this collection, with mentions of events or characters from ‘Emma’, ‘Sense and Sensibility’, and ‘Persuasion’. Emma and her relationship with Mr Knightley are the favourite, with her character described as ‘an analyst before Freud’.
The title poem was one of my absolute favourites. At first it seems very simple, an interview, a fabric rose worn on the interview suit. But there are so many more layers. The disappearing jobs, the Liverpool football shirt and keeper, the anxious wait, all perfectly rendered:
The week of interviews twenty minutes each
to face a panel for my disappearing job.
I went into a shop called Accessory House
and bought a flamboyant fabric rose
of the most arresting red, as arresting as
Liverpool F.C.’s elite Garibaldi red
and pinned it to my black linen jacket.
I sat on a chair in the corridor waiting
wondering what I should say. I had
prepared nothing, it would have to be
spontaneous, from the heart, like the rose
or the Garibaldi goalkeeper with his gloves
straining for the crossbar of the goal or diving
like a salmon in its death throes.
Protect me, rose, I said, as the bell sounded
and I walked in, stiff-backed, and sat.
Good morning, good morning. We like your rose.
Was that a point on the score sheet?
I’m sure I said something foolish. The rose
was causing me to relax. I told it
to keep it together. Remember the worm
that flies in the night. It settled back
on my lapel and nestled against my cheek.
In the corridor again I unpinned it
and held it to my nose. A little perfume
from my wrist had climbed inside it.
The final poem in the collection is also one rich in observation and surprise. It shows us Smither’s keen eye for observation and calm, a sensation that ripples under the surface of many of these poems. The poem is called, with wry irony, ‘Mark Doty: a footnote’:
Walking between venues in Aldeburgh
to attend the next reading or panel
a boy kicks a football in Mark Doty’s path.
Just a poet walking, one of those
removed from the world, a floater,
but look he has scooped up the ball
on the curve of his foot, cradles it
like a bird fallen from a tree,
rolls it up to chest height
then over his shoulder, his other foot
hooks to kick it back to
two astonished boys. A poet
who could play of Chelsea or Real Madrid,
earn a fee greater than any poet,
but greatest of all the way
he goes on chatting to the other poets,
his head lowered, as modestly
he sets the world back in place.
Reviewer: Marcus Hobson
Auckland University Press
