The Surface Trials by H. M. Waugh

H.M. Waugh’s The Surface Trials delivers an electrifying blend of high-stakes survival, intergalactic mystery, and fast-paced action - all under the unrelenting gaze of a universe-wide audience. This thrilling intermediate age science fiction novel catapults readers into a vividly imagined alien world, where danger lurks in every crevice, friendships are tested, and fame comes with a deadly price.

The premise is instantly compelling: every year, hopeful candidates from across the galaxy compete in the Surface Trials to gain entry into Starquest Academy, the elite training ground for future leaders and explorers. Squads of five are dropped onto a partially explored, carnivorous planet and given three days to survive, decipher clues, and make it to the extraction point, preferably with all teammates intact. Meanwhile, an unseen audience watches their every move, offering sponsorships and influence to those who win favour.

Amethyst “Ammy” Antares, the story’s fiercely intelligent and determined protagonist, brings a deeply personal motivation to the Trials. Hailing from a planet mistrusted by the rest of the galaxy, Ammy sees Starquest not just as opportunity, but as salvation. Her voice is a blend of defiance, vulnerability, and sharp observation, making her easy to root for. Alongside her are other memorable characters, including the enigmatic Deneb and the undercover celebrity Rian (heir to the galaxy’s ruling dynasties) who hides his identity behind a clever disguise.

Though comparisons to The Hunger Games or The Maze Runner are inevitable, Waugh’s novel distinguishes itself by substituting brutality with collaboration. The Trials emphasise teamwork and moral choice; contestants succeed not by outlasting others, but by supporting each other under pressure. This shift from conflict-driven competition to cooperative survival offers a refreshing take on the dystopian quest format and makes the story suitable for younger readers without sacrificing tension.

Waugh excels at world-building, introducing a vivid and unpredictable environment teeming with oversized insects, carnivorous plants, and psychological hazards. The planet itself feels alive, and its hostility isn’t just physical - it gets into the characters' minds. Add to that the ever-present surveillance, public speculation about the secret heir among the contestants, and the whispers of a dangerous illegal power called Mindbreaking, and you have a richly layered narrative that keeps readers guessing.

The writing strikes a satisfying balance between pace and depth. There’s plenty of action: chases, standoffs, betrayals, but also heart and humour. The dialogue is wonderful, the emotional arcs are genuine, and the plot twists are not only surprising but meaningful. Most impressively, the story respects its audience, trusting younger readers to handle moral complexity and ambiguous motivations.

In all, The Surface Trials is a standout in contemporary middle-grade science fiction. It manages to be both fun and thought-provoking, delivering excitement and empathy in equal measure. Waugh’s vision of a future where survival depends on collaboration, not domination, feels like exactly the story today’s readers need.

Highly recommended for readers aged 10+ who love sci-fi, teamwork, and a twisty, heart-pounding adventure.

Reviewer: Chris Reed

Allen & Unwin