top of page

Farewell to Eden by Sebastian Faulks

Writer: NZ Booklovers
NZ Booklovers
11 minutes ago
5 min read


Farewell to Eden follows the story of Philip Deval over a period of thirty-odd years from 1946 as far as the 1980s. We begin the novel in 1951 when Philip arrives at a school in the English countryside to take up a post teaching French. It is his first job as a teacher, and although nervous, he takes it in his stride. When he is asked to referee the girls’ netball games, he has to learn the rules from an encyclopaedia.

 

Throughout this description of post-war gloom, where rationing still limits the diet, there are occasional hints at something mysterious in Philip’s past. He was in the British Army during the war and survived the landings in Normandy. At the school, he meets the very reserved music teacher, Frances Darwood. Gradually, a friendship develops, based on music and awkward conversations, until at last they are able to tell each other some of their past histories. We hop back to 1946, when Philip was stationed in Palestine as part of the British peacekeeping mission in the final days of the British Mandate. Soon the state of Israel will be created and land divided between Jews, Arabs and Muslims. We see Philip conflicted between behind-the-scenes political manoeuvring and the peoples who have lived in the land for thousands of years. His friend Matthew Kilvert is the military padre, thrilled to visit the famous places mentioned in the New Testament. Philip claims not to be religious but still knows his bible well. He feels the weight of history in the Middle East situation. As Sebastian Faulks comments in his author’s note at the end, few of us have read or understood the history of this time, and how it has led to the current situations such as war in Gaza and the wider Middle East.


As Philip tries to keep the peace, he and his company of men are under threat from all sides, from terrorists, the police, and also the arrival of displaced Jews from across the whole of post-war Europe. There are bomb attacks and Faulks does well to conjure up the confusion of the many different factions.


This piece of dialogue reveals the confusion about the many different factions:

‘Are they all as bad?”

‘As a rule of thumb, I always think it goes: Haganah, fine. They’re regular army. Then Palmach, iffy. Irgun are terrorists. They have a political basis and they have ambitions - to take as much land here as possible for their people. But they will kill without scruple to make their point - as we saw in the King David. Lehi - or the Stern Gang as we call them - are straightforward murderers. Kill anything that moves. They have similar aims as Irgan but no political sense or programme. Their leader, Mr Stern himself, was in league with the Nazis.’

‘I see.’

‘And of course the terrorists use the tactics we taught them. And if they kill a hundred fellow Jews along the way it’s of no consequence to them. Compared to the millions of their people they’ve seen exterminated in Europe.’

Philip stood up to go. ‘And it all seemed so pleasant here in Galilee.’

‘It still is. A promised land.’ Knox turned to look out of the window. ‘I just wish it hadn’t been promised to quite so many people.’

 

Another passage describes Philip’s reaction to the closely pressed group of men in a bar called Dov’s grog shop in Jerusalem:

For all their differences, they were talking, playing dice and cards in a mix of tongues, united by a wish for company.

Soon they would be killing one another. The harmony of Dov’s grog shop was something they were unable to replicate on a larger scale. Humans had worked out the movements of the planets and prised apart the individual atom; they’d cured mysterious diseases and found a way, by trade, of making themselves richer than the sum of their possessions; they’d built the world’s most wondrous city on water - to say nothing of all they’d made in art and music. But a group of closely related people in a fertile landscape couldn’t find a way to coexist. Politics was the thing people couldn’t do. In the end they would opt for massacre.

 

These long flashbacks of Philip’s life allow him to reveal his relationship with Alice, a fellow student at Cambridge before the war, with whom he was secretly engaged, but who fell ill and died leaving Philip shocked, angry and seemingly unable to form relationships with other women. We gradually come to understand Philip and the conflict between the philosophy he studied, his inability to accept a religious faith, and the impact of the loss of his men and friends during the war. These are all things he continues to struggle with all his life. By contrast, Frances Darwood’s story seems simple, but more horrific. She was rounded up along with her mother and taken to one of the concentration camps where she was made to work. Separated from her mother, she would never see her again. This little exchange with Philip was interesting:

‘You were working in the Siemens factory.’

‘Yes. I found out later that they paid us. Forty pfennigs an hour. But we never saw the money because they gave our wages to the camp office. So in effect they rented us from the SS.’

Frances was lucky to be moved and to be able to teach music to the children of the SS officers from the camp. Then she worked salvaging uniforms from dead soldiers. One night the soldiers came and loaded a group of prisoners into trucks and drove through the night. Deep in the forest twenty of the women were handed over to a bus painted with the Red Cross. The rest were probably shot, but Frances was taken to safety. It is a powerful story and much closer to the horrors of war that anything we heard from Philip. 


Our view of Philip is always from a distance, and at times he is hard to fathom as a central character; his beliefs, or lack of them, often causing him to be uncertain. The last section of the book moves us forwards quickly from 1961 to 1981, and takes us on a series of surprising and unsettling leaps, as well as some entirely unexpected consequences of actions that happened years before. Those initial hints of something mysterious in Philip’s past all play out in unexpected ways that the reader may not see coming.


Sebastian Faulks is a great storyteller. You only have to look at his sixteen previous works of fiction, not to mention the non-fiction, to know that there are some great stories being told. This latest novel is another to follow in the tradition.


Reviewer: Marcus Hobson

Penguin


© 2018 NZ Booklovers. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page